How we rate forex, stock and crypto brokers, explained in plain English with worked examples, so you know exactly how every score and ranking is made.
Last updated: 26 October 2026
Editorial Rating: what we score
Our 0-10 Editorial Rating measures every broker against the same five pillars. Each pillar carries a fixed weight in the overall rating.
Regulation & Safety
30%
Licences held, the quality of each regulator, client-fund protection, negative balance protection, and any regulatory warnings or enforcement history.
Costs & Fees
25%
Typical spreads, commissions, swap/overnight fees, deposit and withdrawal charges, and any inactivity or hidden fees.
Platforms & Products
20%
Range of markets, available trading platforms, order types, tools, execution quality, and the mobile experience.
Service & Experience
15%
Account opening speed, funding options, customer support quality and hours, education, and overall usability.
Trader Feedback
10%
Verified user reviews, complaint volume and resolution, and how the broker responds to disputes over time.
How we review
The same repeatable process is followed for every broker, so results stay consistent and comparable.
1. Gather the facts
We collect data directly from the broker, its public documents, and — for regulation — the regulator's own public register. Nothing is taken on trust.
2. Score against fixed criteria
Each broker is scored against the same weighted pillars using the same checklist, so scores are comparable across every broker on the platform.
3. Verify & record the source
Key claims — especially regulation and licensing — are checked against official sources, dated, and logged so we can show when each fact was last confirmed.
4. Review & re-check
Ratings are reviewed regularly and whenever material information changes. Verification dates on each profile show you how current our checks are.
Two numbers, two jobs
Editorial Rating (0-10)
Our analysts' opinion of how good a broker is to trade with, scored on the five pillars above. It reflects costs, platforms and service as well as safety.
BrokerBazaar Score (0-100)
An independent, evidence-only score computed by fixed rules from data we can verify ourselves: regulator registers, domain records, web archives and public reviews. No opinion, no AI judgement, and no way to pay for points.
BrokerBazaar Score: the five signals
Each signal is scored 0-100 from verifiable evidence, then combined with these fixed weights. Missing data lowers our Data Confidence figure, never the score itself. Read the full rule-by-rule method.
Regulation
34%
Licences we can check on a regulator's public register, the number of regulated entities, our verification status, and any official warnings.
Transparency
20%
Whether the legal entity, registered address, contact details, website, disclosures and trading costs are all published.
Reputation
20%
Public review ratings and volume on independent sites, plus ratings from other trusted review platforms.
Domain & History
16%
How long the broker's domain has been registered, whether it is secured with HTTPS, and how far back its archived web history goes.
Digital Presence
10%
Independent web-footprint data: domain authority, referring domains and traffic trend. Deliberately a small slice.
Regulatory warning override. If a regulator that licenses the broker issues a warning, its BrokerBazaar Score is capped at 40 and the risk level is set to High until the matter is resolved, regardless of how strong its other signals are. Warnings from countries where the broker holds no licence lower the score by at most 5 points in total. Scores are also labelled by band: 90+ Excellent Verification, 80+ Strong, 70+ Good, 60+ Moderate, 50+ Elevated Attention, 35+ High Attention, below 35 Serious Risk Indicators.
Worked scoring examples
Three illustrative broker profiles run through the exact same rules engine that scores every broker on BrokerBazaar. The figures below are calculated live from the stated evidence, not typed in by hand. The profiles are composites and do not describe any specific broker.
Example A: multi-regulated, long-established broker
Two licences we could check on the regulators' own registers, every disclosure published, a domain registered for over a decade and a large public review base.
Evidence we recorded
3 stated regulators, 2 licences linked to a public register entry
Legal entity, address, phone, email, terms and pricing all published
Domain registered 11 years ago, archived since 2015, served over HTTPS
12,000 public reviews averaging 4.1 out of 5, plus one other rated platform
About 600,000 monthly visits, 3,200 referring domains
How the score is built
Signal
Score
Weight
Points
Regulation
90
34%
30.6
Transparency
100
20%
20.0
Reputation
96
20%
19.2
Domain & History
100
16%
16.0
Digital Presence
80
10%
8.0
Weighted total
94
94/ 100
Excellent Verification
Low risk · Data Confidence 96/100
Why it lands here: Regulation and transparency are maxed out from checkable facts. The third regulator adds nothing extra because the verified-licence bonus is capped: only licences we can confirm ourselves count toward it.
Example B: single-licence broker, two years old, no public reviews yet
One verifiable licence and most company details published, but costs are not disclosed, the domain is young and there is no independent web or review data.
Evidence we recorded
1 regulator, licence linked to the public register
Legal entity, address and contact details published; spreads and commission not disclosed
Domain registered 2 years ago, first archived in 2024
No public review rating and no traffic or authority data available
How the score is built
Signal
Score
Weight
Points
Regulation
60
34%
20.4
Transparency
75
20%
15.0
Reputation
70
20%
14.0
Domain & History
45
16%
7.2
Digital Presence
35
10%
3.5
Weighted total
60
60/ 100
Moderate
Elevated risk · Data Confidence 80/100
Why it lands here: Missing data is treated as not available, not as zero. Reputation falls back to our editorial view, and Digital Presence sits at its neutral baseline. The gaps show up in the lower Data Confidence figure instead of crushing the score. Publishing costs alone would add 15 points to Transparency.
Example C: strong history, but a live regulatory warning
On paper a well-established, fully transparent broker. A regulator has published an official warning about it, which triggers the cap.
Evidence we recorded
2 verifiable licences and an independently verified entity
1 official regulatory warning currently published
All company and cost disclosures present
Domain registered 9 years ago; traffic down 30% over six months
4,000 public reviews averaging 3.6 out of 5
How the score is built
Signal
Score
Weight
Points
Regulation
70
34%
23.8
Transparency
100
20%
20.0
Reputation
89
20%
17.8
Domain & History
90
16%
14.4
Digital Presence
64
10%
6.4
Weighted total
82
Regulatory warning cap applied
min(total, 40)
40/ 100
High Attention
High risk · Data Confidence 100/100
Why it lands here: The weighted total would land in the 80s, but an official warning deducts 30 from Regulation and then caps the whole score at 40 with a High risk level. No amount of history or marketing can offset a live warning.
Worked example: the 0-10 Editorial Rating
An analyst scores each pillar out of 10 against the published checklist. The pillar scores are multiplied by their fixed weights and summed. Here is a typical mid-to-upper rating.
Pillar
Pillar score
Weight
Contribution
Regulation & Safety
9.0
30%
2.70
Costs & Fees
7.5
25%
1.88
Platforms & Products
8.0
20%
1.60
Service & Experience
7.0
15%
1.05
Trader Feedback
6.5
10%
0.65
Editorial Rating
7.9 / 10
A broker with cheaper pricing but a weaker regulator would score higher on Costs and lower on Regulation; because Regulation carries 30% against 25% for Costs, the safer broker usually rates higher overall. Every pillar score is backed by notes and sources an editor can show.
Each profile also shows six section scores: Safety, Costs, Funding, Platforms & Tools, Accounts and Support. They list every point, never count missing facts as zero, and do not change the BrokerBazaar Score.
Every point on the BrokerBazaar Score comes from a fact we can independently confirm. The only way up is to become more regulated, more transparent and better reviewed, and to give us the evidence. Nothing here can be purchased.
Regulation
Hold a licence from a recognised financial regulator and publish the licence number. Regulation is the single heaviest factor.
Give us the direct link to your entry on the regulator's public register. A licence we can check ourselves is worth roughly double a licence that is only stated.
Hold licences in more than one jurisdiction. Each additional regulated entity adds points, up to a cap.
Complete our verification process so your entity and licence are marked independently verified.
Resolve any warning from a regulator that licenses you. While it is live the overall score is capped at 40. Warnings from countries where you hold no licence cost at most 5 points in total.
Transparency
Publish the full legal entity name and company registration number.
Publish a registered office address that matches your regulator and review-site profiles.
Show a working phone number and support email.
Disclose typical spreads and commissions for every account type. Undisclosed costs score zero on that item.
Make your terms, risk disclosures and client agreements easy to find.
Reputation
Earn genuine reviews on independent platforms such as Trustpilot. The average rating drives most of this signal.
Build review volume: passing 100 reviews and then 1,000 reviews each adds a bonus because larger samples are harder to skew.
Respond to negative reviews and resolve complaints; our editorial team reviews complaint handling.
Ratings on additional trusted review sites add a small further lift.
Domain & History
Keep operating on the same primary domain. Points are added at 1, 3, 5 and 10 years of registration age, and again for 3 and 8 years of archived history.
Serve the website over HTTPS with a valid certificate.
Avoid rebranding to a new domain: a fresh domain resets this signal even if the company is old.
Digital Presence
Grow an authentic web footprint: coverage from reputable finance sites, partners and regulators raises domain authority and referring domains.
Sustain healthy traffic growth. A sharp decline in visitors is a small negative signal.
This signal is capped at 10% by design, so marketing spend alone cannot move the overall score meaningfully.
Submit evidence, not requests
Brokers who claim their profile can send us register links, corporate documents and updated cost disclosures. We re-run the same fixed rules on the new evidence and the score updates automatically. We never adjust a number by hand. Claiming a profile or paying has no effect on the evidence-only score; brokers with independently verified disclosures can earn a separately labelled bonus of up to 10 points.
Ratings are never for sale
No broker can pay to improve its score or ranking. Advertising and commercial partnerships are kept separate from our editorial scoring. See exactly how the business is funded on our How we make money page.
What each evidence label means
Every fact on a profile carries a label that says where it came from. We never use a stronger label than the evidence supports.
Updated by broker: the broker entered or changed this in its own panel. It is shown with the date of the change, and the previous value stays in the profile history.
Checked against an official source: our team matched the fact to a regulator register, the broker's official documents or its published pricing page, and recorded the link and the date.
Observed on a broker-supplied account: data read from an account the broker connected to us. It shows what we observed on that account during that period, not a certification of execution quality.
Independently tested by BrokerBazaar: our own documented test, such as opening an account or making a deposit and a withdrawal, with dates and screenshots.
Not verified: we have the figure but have not confirmed it yet. It never counts as a confirmed fact in the score.
Data confidence and update policy
Next to every BrokerBazaar Score we show a Data Confidence figure from 0 to 100. It rises with each independent source we could check (regulator register, domain registry, web archive, public reviews and web data). A high score with low confidence means "promising, but not yet verified".
Automatic checks (domain, archive, web data) refresh on a regular cycle. Licence and regulation facts are re-checked when the broker submits a change, when a regulator publishes a warning, and during periodic reviews. Fees and spreads change often, so each figure shows the date it was last checked. When an old figure is replaced, the earlier value stays in the profile history instead of being overwritten.
Editorial independence
Our ratings and reviews are produced by our editorial team, which operates independently from our commercial team. Commercial relationships and advertising spend do not influence a broker's score, ranking, or review.
We earn revenue from subscriptions, paid visibility, media, Launchpad campaigns and data services — never from broker deposit or trading commissions. No broker can pay to change its score or ranking, and commercial placements are clearly labelled. You can read the full detail on our "How we make money" page.
Where our data comes from
Broker information is sourced from the brokers themselves, their official documentation, and public regulatory registers. Costs such as spreads and commissions are indicative and can change frequently — always confirm the latest figures directly with the broker before trading.
We work to keep every profile accurate and up to date. If you believe something is wrong, you can report it and we will review it.
What our ratings are — and are not
Our scores are a research tool to help you compare brokers on a like-for-like basis. They are not a recommendation, endorsement, or financial advice, and they are not a guarantee of any broker's future conduct or performance.
The right broker for you depends on your own circumstances, goals, and the rules in your country. Always do your own due diligence and consider independent professional advice before opening an account.
Ratings methodology FAQ
How does BrokerBazaar rate forex brokers?
Every broker gets two numbers. The Editorial Rating (0-10) is our analysts' assessment across five weighted pillars: Regulation & Safety 30%, Costs & Fees 25%, Platforms & Products 20%, Service & Experience 15% and Trader Feedback 10%. The BrokerBazaar Score (0-100) is computed by fixed rules from evidence we can verify ourselves, with Regulation weighted 34%, Transparency 20%, Reputation 20%, Domain & History 16% and Digital Presence 10%.
Can a broker pay to improve its rating or ranking?
No. Commercial relationships, advertising and memberships cannot buy a higher evidence-only score or ranking. Separately, brokers that publish independently verified disclosures can earn a clearly labelled bonus of up to 10 points, shown apart from the evidence-only score. The BrokerBazaar Score is computed by deterministic rules from verifiable facts, and the editorial team works independently of the commercial team.
What happens to a broker's score if a regulator issues a warning?
An official regulatory warning deducts points from the Regulation signal and caps the overall BrokerBazaar Score at 40 with a High risk level until the matter is resolved, regardless of how strong the broker's other signals are.
What does Data Confidence mean?
Data Confidence (0-100) shows how much independent evidence backed the score: regulator registers, domain registry records, web archives, public reviews and web data. Missing data lowers confidence rather than the score, so a high score with low confidence means promising but not yet fully verified.